romanhn 2 days ago

The Alki Beach example is absolute madness. On one hand, I can't wait until all thousands of my photos get automatic semantic and geographic tagging (I guess that's possible now). On the other, goodbye privacy, we hardly knew ye. It will be interesting to apply this to historical, or just old, photos.

4
jsheard 2 days ago

> The Alki Beach example is absolute madness.

I wonder about info leakage with that one, the poster uses that exact photo as their avatar so if they've mentioned Alki Beach before then reverse image searching might pick it up from context. Ideally you'd want to test it with a photo that's never been posted online.

omalled 2 days ago

I also wonder how much the memory feature plays a role. I gave it a picture of the street I live on that isn’t online anywhere. O3 guessed the town correctly. Then, I turned off the memory feature and did the same thing. It didn’t even get the state right.

beoberha 2 days ago

Assuming it only used the pixels and not any metadata from the file or memory from the user (which is a massive assumption), how fucking cool that it can identify the Olympics versus any other mountain range. At that point it’s probably not too hard to guess the picture came from Alki or Golden Gardens, but still very impressive!

I’m also completely ignoring it inferred location from the pride flag and corgi which have heavy Seattle vibes :)

weregiraffe 2 days ago

>goodbye privacy, we hardly knew ye.

Don't upload your private photos anywhere.

bee_rider 2 days ago

Of course, it is pretty impressive.

It isn’t magic. I think there we’ll often be surprised by the “hits,” but it’ll also get a lot of “misses.” A random photo in your back yard that doesn’t show the horizon will probably be a miss, right?

Meanwhile, lots of photos already include GPS coordinates… data you can strip out, but which is enabled by default for millions of people. Privacy, eh, never knew it I guess.

xnickb 2 days ago

It's a fallacy to assume that one didn't have privacy merely because most people opted out of it due to personal reasons.

bee_rider 2 days ago

Which fallacy is it, out of curiosity?