7e 4 days ago

Dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43476793

Decades have passed and HN still can’t automatically dedup submissions.

4
js2 4 days ago

Usually it does de-dupe any submission with "significant attention", but I'm not sure what the threshold for that is.

I'd think the submissions from two days ago (206 points, 93 comments) would have qualified. (It's the exact same URL so that's not why it wasn't de-duped either.)

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

joatmon-snoo 4 days ago

Pretty sure dedupe is done manually by u/dang.

js2 4 days ago

Yes, he can manually merge duplicate submissions and their comments.

But there's times when I've submitted items that are dupes and it just takes me to the recent submission and adds an upvote. Now here's something weird: I just tested this by submitting the URL from this submission with the same title and it immediately took me to the discussion from two days ago.

So I'm really confused how this dupe got through.

yb303 4 days ago

Why dedup? Old forgotten things are as good as new :)

usr1106 4 days ago

2 years might be OK, but not 2 days as in this case.

montag 4 days ago

I'm ok with dupes. But cross-linking should at least be automatic.

khimaros 4 days ago

i use the open source Glider frontend on Android and it shows related posts automatically. recommended.

efilife 4 days ago

Isn't this intentional? How would deduping work?