clwg 1 day ago

Just opensource the firmware and redirect the update url.

2
wmf 1 day ago

That doesn't set a good precedent though. The community shouldn't be expected to carry every IoT device.

doubled112 1 day ago

Maybe not, but it'd be nice to have the option. Wouldn't it?

wmf 1 day ago

If you as a user want third-party firmware usually you can jailbreak and install it yourself (especially if the original firmware has zero security). If we allow a vendor to choose to make "the community" responsible for their firmware, almost every vendor will choose that as quickly as possible (e.g. one year).

OtomotO 1 day ago

That's why in sane countries there is jurisdiction to deal with that.

If you leave capitalism unchecked it will fuck you as hard as any other system.

rbetts 1 day ago

This assumes that vendors have IP rights to open source the firmware, which seems unlikely. Presumably there are third party commercial components they don't have rights to publish.

A rule like this essentially forbids closed source software. (Which, hey, might be a good thing... but then just mandate that directly and outlaw closed source software licensing.)