openrisk 4 days ago

That seems only partly true. We did already have punctuation marks (like !?) that are a form of picture writing to modulate the underlying alphabetic meaning.

The smiley was invented because a pure alphabetic script does not do a good job expressing emotions, especially in short isolated sentences.

Emojis are overused in some current contexts (smartphone/messaging addiction) but some sort of standardization along with "emoji" literacy is, in principle, an evolution of the alphabet towards more sophistication and nuance.

1
WalterBright 4 days ago

Emojis are not quite the same thing as picture writing (icons).

I used emojis for a while, then got kinda sick of them.

> a pure alphabetic script does not do a good job expressing emotions

Instead of a smiley emoji, I'll write "haha". Instead of a barf emoji, I write "barf". English has a million words in it. I'm sure you can find a variety of words that express emotions just fine.

?! being a form of picture writing? I don't see it.

int_19h 3 days ago

What makes "?!" different from emoji in your eyes, exactly? It literally encodes emotional delivery of the sentence to which it is applied.