thanksgiving 5 days ago

I don’t get it. He said gripe to his superior but he is basically kissing ass?

3
inopinatus 5 days ago

No, that is exactly how you inform a superior officer that you believe the mission is a waste of time, effort, equipment, and manpower, and will probably get everyone killed for next-to-no benefit.

rendall 4 days ago

I interpreted it to mean that he was still Captain and part of his job was to keep up morale and model positive attitude. Even hypothetically, he was not going to gripe to his troops, and as far as they are concerned, he believes it is a worthy mission. He was jokingly modeling the proper, positive attitude. All this was understood by his men.

stoperaticless 4 days ago

I’d add that the answer was clearly over the top, thus sarcastic, thus he is agreement with his soldiers.

rendall 4 days ago

No, I did not interpret it that way. Perhaps he did think the mission was dumb, but he was not letting on even subtly.

unethical_ban 4 days ago

It's best understood in the context of the story. I highly recommend the movie.

He's being sarcastic about his approval of the mission they're on, but is making the point of not overtly complaining to his unit.